In Halo 3, when Truth fires all the Halo rings, there is a destroyed one, that does not light. This would be the Halo ring you destroyed in the first game. :
Halo Ring Locations Infographic : r/halo
Where are the Halo rings in the new Halo show? - WIN.gg
The Halo Ring - Glow Ring by Carbon6
Belk 1.43 ct. t.w. Moissanite Cushion Halo Ring 14K Gold | The Summit
Cline Custom Round Diamond Halo Ring - Cline Jewelers
Double Halo Triple Shank Engagement Ring With Elongated Radiant Cut - Good Stone Inc
14K White Gold Solitaire Halo Diamond Engagement Ring
Oval Ruby with Diamond & Ruby Halo Ring in White Gold | Borsheims